Considering New Construction? Talk to Matthew before a model home visit 561 504-4798

Jax Property
Jax Property
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Search Homes
  • Toll Brothers
    • Shores at RiverTown
    • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
    • Regency at EverRange
    • Sebastian Landing
    • Bartram Ranch
    • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
    • Communities
    • RiverTown
    • Nocatee
    • SilverLeaf
    • EverRange
  • Compare
    • Compare Builders
    • Builder Lender vs. Yours
    • Ready vs. To-Build
    • New vs. Custom
    • New vs. Resale
  • Worksheets
    • Real All-In Cost
    • Lot Premium Review
    • Upgrade Scorecard
    • Floor Plan Worksheet
    • Builder Comparison
    • Real Cost of a Home
  • Start Here
    • New Construction Buyers
    • Before You Register
    • Talk to me before touring
    • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • 55+ Buyer Guide
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews
  • More
    • Home
    • Guides
    • Search Homes
    • Toll Brothers
      • Shores at RiverTown
      • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
      • Regency at EverRange
      • Sebastian Landing
      • Bartram Ranch
      • Toll vs. Builders
    • Toll Brothers Guide
    • Communities
      • Communities
      • RiverTown
      • Nocatee
      • SilverLeaf
      • EverRange
    • Compare
      • Compare Builders
      • Builder Lender vs. Yours
      • Ready vs. To-Build
      • New vs. Custom
      • New vs. Resale
    • Worksheets
      • Real All-In Cost
      • Lot Premium Review
      • Upgrade Scorecard
      • Floor Plan Worksheet
      • Builder Comparison
      • Real Cost of a Home
    • Start Here
      • New Construction Buyers
      • Before You Register
      • Talk to me before touring
      • South Florida Relocation
    • About Matthew Sodel
    • Sell or Build First
    • 55+ Buyer Guide
    • SJC Buyer's Agent
    • Reviews
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Search Homes
  • Toll Brothers
    • Shores at RiverTown
    • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
    • Regency at EverRange
    • Sebastian Landing
    • Bartram Ranch
    • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
    • Communities
    • RiverTown
    • Nocatee
    • SilverLeaf
    • EverRange
  • Compare
    • Compare Builders
    • Builder Lender vs. Yours
    • Ready vs. To-Build
    • New vs. Custom
    • New vs. Resale
  • Worksheets
    • Real All-In Cost
    • Lot Premium Review
    • Upgrade Scorecard
    • Floor Plan Worksheet
    • Builder Comparison
    • Real Cost of a Home
  • Start Here
    • New Construction Buyers
    • Before You Register
    • Talk to me before touring
    • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • 55+ Buyer Guide
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews

Toll Brothers vs. Weekley vs. ICI vs. Dream Finders

The short answer

In St. Johns County, Toll Brothers, David Weekley, ICI Homes, and Dream Finders all build good houses and all offer roughly the same warranty structure. They differ in how much you can change the plan, how they price lots and upgrades, how they structure incentives, and how they handle the build itself. Which one fits you depends on whether you want control, speed, or price.


I don't work for any of them. I've walked buyers through all four.

How do the four builders compare at a glance?

Toll Brothers

Typical St. Johns price point: upper $600Ks to $1M+. Personalization: structural options plus a large design studio. Warranty: one-year workmanship, two-year systems, ten-year structural (confirm at the sales office). Incentive style: design-studio credits, rate buydowns through Toll Brothers Mortgage, quick-move-in discounts. Builds at Shores at RiverTown, Newbrook at SilverLeaf, Regency at EverRange, Sebastian Landing, Bartram Ranch, and Crosswinds at Nocatee.


David Weekley Homes

Typical St. Johns price point: mid $600Ks to $900Ks. Personalization: structural options plus a design center. Warranty: one, two, and ten years, serviced by Weekley's own warranty team. Incentive style: closing-cost and rate help, often tied to the in-house lender. Builds in Nocatee (Seabrook Village, Coral Ridge, Crosswinds) and RiverTown.


ICI Homes

Typical St. Johns price point: $700Ks to $1M+. Personalization: semi-custom; plan changes are possible. Warranty: one, two, and ten years, administered through 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty. Incentive style: price and closing-cost incentives with lender tie-ins. Builds at Middlebourne, Madeira, Seabrook Village, Coral Ridge, and West End at Town Center.


Dream Finders Homes

Typical St. Johns price point: $400Ks to $700Ks. Personalization: mostly pre-set packages. Warranty: one, two, and ten years (confirm at the sales office). Incentive style: aggressive rate buydowns through Jet HomeLoans and closing-cost credits. Builds at SilverLeaf, Creekside Estates, and EverRange.


Price points are what I see in current price sheets and recorded closings. One MLS-based tally through mid-2026 put Toll's median St. Johns closing near $765,500, David Weekley's near $677,080, and ICI's near $964,420. Dream Finders sells largely outside the MLS and was not counted.

Which builder gives you the most control over the plan?

ICI, then Toll. ICI operates closer to semi-custom and will entertain plan changes that production builders won't. Toll offers a long menu of structural options and a large design studio, but the menu is the menu. David Weekley sits in the middle. Dream Finders is built for speed and price, with curated packages and fewer structural choices.


More control is not free. Every structural option and design-studio selection is a profit center. See the guide Are Lot Premiums Negotiable? for how I approach the add-ons.

Which builder is the most negotiable?

It changes quarter to quarter, and it changes by inventory. A builder with six finished spec homes sitting in one community is far more flexible than the same builder with a waitlist in another. In general, quick-move-in homes at any of the four are more negotiable than to-be-built homes, and incentives are usually tied to using the builder's lender. Read Builder Lender vs. Yours before you accept that trade.

How does the warranty actually differ?

On paper, very little. All four follow the one-year workmanship, two-year systems, ten-year structural pattern that's standard in Florida new construction. The difference is who services it. David Weekley handles warranty through its own team. ICI runs claims through 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty, a third-party administrator. Toll and Dream Finders each have their own process. Ask for the full warranty document before you sign, not at closing.


What matters more than the document is the builder's local warranty reputation, and that's community-specific. Ask neighbors who closed 18 months ago.

Which builder is right for a relocation buyer?

If you're moving from out of state and can't visit often, Toll and David Weekley have the most predictable processes and the most communication built in. If you want a home that feels custom and you can be hands-on, ICI. If budget is the constraint and you want to be in a home in 60 to 90 days, Dream Finders' inventory is where I'd start looking.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a different agent for each builder?

No. One independent agent can represent you at all four. You register me on your first visit to each sales office. The guide Builder Rep vs. Your Agent explains why that first visit matters.


Is the most expensive builder the best built?

Not necessarily. Price reflects land cost, finish level, and brand more than framing quality. All four build to the same Florida Building Code. Get a third-party inspection on any of them.


Can I use the Builder Comparison worksheet for this?

Yes. That worksheet is built to put two or three builders' quotes side by side on an all-in basis.

Deciding between two of these builders?

Tell me which two and which community. I'll tell you what I've seen there lately. No obligation. Call or text 561-504-4798, or email matthew@newhomesjax.com.


Matthew Sodel, Real Estate Advisor and Certified New Home Specialist, Highlight Realty. Independent buyer representation for new construction in Jacksonville and St. Johns County.

Matthew Sodel, Real Estate Advisor & Certified New Home Specialist, Highlight Realty, FL SL3216518, 561-504-4798, matthew@newhomesjax.com, jax-property.com

Powered by

  • Shores at RiverTown
  • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
  • Regency at EverRange
  • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
  • RiverTown
  • Nocatee
  • SilverLeaf
  • EverRange
  • Compare Builders
  • Builder Lender vs. Yours
  • Ready vs. To-Build
  • New vs. Custom
  • New vs. Resale
  • Real All-In Cost
  • Lot Premium Review
  • Upgrade Scorecard
  • Floor Plan Worksheet
  • Builder Comparison
  • Real Cost of a Home
  • New Construction Buyers
  • Before You Register
  • Talk to me before touring
  • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • Privacy Policy
  • How I Work
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept