Considering New Construction? Talk to Matthew before a model home visit 561 504-4798

Jax Property
Jax Property
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Search Homes
  • Toll Brothers
    • Shores at RiverTown
    • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
    • Regency at EverRange
    • Sebastian Landing
    • Bartram Ranch
    • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
    • Communities
    • RiverTown
    • Nocatee
    • SilverLeaf
    • EverRange
  • Compare
    • Compare Builders
    • Builder Lender vs. Yours
    • Ready vs. To-Build
    • New vs. Custom
    • New vs. Resale
  • Worksheets
    • Real All-In Cost
    • Lot Premium Review
    • Upgrade Scorecard
    • Floor Plan Worksheet
    • Builder Comparison
    • Real Cost of a Home
  • Start Here
    • New Construction Buyers
    • Before You Register
    • Talk to me before touring
    • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • 55+ Buyer Guide
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews
  • More
    • Home
    • Guides
    • Search Homes
    • Toll Brothers
      • Shores at RiverTown
      • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
      • Regency at EverRange
      • Sebastian Landing
      • Bartram Ranch
      • Toll vs. Builders
    • Toll Brothers Guide
    • Communities
      • Communities
      • RiverTown
      • Nocatee
      • SilverLeaf
      • EverRange
    • Compare
      • Compare Builders
      • Builder Lender vs. Yours
      • Ready vs. To-Build
      • New vs. Custom
      • New vs. Resale
    • Worksheets
      • Real All-In Cost
      • Lot Premium Review
      • Upgrade Scorecard
      • Floor Plan Worksheet
      • Builder Comparison
      • Real Cost of a Home
    • Start Here
      • New Construction Buyers
      • Before You Register
      • Talk to me before touring
      • South Florida Relocation
    • About Matthew Sodel
    • Sell or Build First
    • 55+ Buyer Guide
    • SJC Buyer's Agent
    • Reviews
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Search Homes
  • Toll Brothers
    • Shores at RiverTown
    • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
    • Regency at EverRange
    • Sebastian Landing
    • Bartram Ranch
    • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
    • Communities
    • RiverTown
    • Nocatee
    • SilverLeaf
    • EverRange
  • Compare
    • Compare Builders
    • Builder Lender vs. Yours
    • Ready vs. To-Build
    • New vs. Custom
    • New vs. Resale
  • Worksheets
    • Real All-In Cost
    • Lot Premium Review
    • Upgrade Scorecard
    • Floor Plan Worksheet
    • Builder Comparison
    • Real Cost of a Home
  • Start Here
    • New Construction Buyers
    • Before You Register
    • Talk to me before touring
    • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • 55+ Buyer Guide
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews
NEW CONSTRUCTION BUYER GUIDE

Are lot premiums negotiable on a new construction home?

Sometimes, and less often than buyers hope. The premium is usually the last thing a builder will discount and the first thing they will offset with something else. The useful question is not "will you drop the premium" but "what are you willing to do about the premium."

Why builders defend the premium number

Premiums are set per lot on a pricing sheet the sales office doesn't control. Lowering one creates a comp that every later buyer in the phase will point to, and it drags the appraisal baseline down for the builder's own future closings. That is why the rep will tell you the premium is firm, and why they are usually telling the truth about their own authority.


What the sales office can usually do is add value on the other side of the ledger: design studio credit, closing cost contribution, a rate buydown through the preferred lender, included options, or a flex on the deposit schedule.


A typical version of how that plays out: a buyer wants a preserve lot carrying a $35,000 premium and asks for it at $20,000. The sales office says no. The same buyer asks instead for the premium to stay and for $15,000 in design studio credit plus the builder covering the lender's title and closing costs. That request gets approved, because it doesn't touch the lot pricing sheet and it comes out of a different budget. Same dollars to the buyer, different answer from the builder.

When premiums do move

End of quarter and end of fiscal year, when a builder needs the closing on the books. For most of the national builders active in St. Johns County that means late March, late June, late September, and the last two weeks of the year, with the fiscal year-end varying by builder.


Standing inventory, where a home on a premium lot has sat past the builder's internal days-on-market threshold. Once a spec home has carried for several months, the premium becomes the softest number in the price.


Lots at the back of a phase when the next phase has already opened at higher base prices. The builder wants the old phase closed out, and the premium on the last few lots is in the way.


And the rare case where a lot has a feature the builder would rather credit than explain: an easement, a drainage swale, a utility box or lift station on the front corner, or a future road connection behind the preserve line.

What a premium is actually buying you

Water view, preserve backing, cul-de-sac, corner, oversized, or simply no rear neighbor. Each has a different resale story.


Preserve backing with a recorded conservation easement holds value because it can't change. Pond frontage holds value unless the pond is a stormwater retention cell that gets drawn down and dredged. A corner lot is a premium to the builder and a discount to many buyers, who see traffic on two sides and a bigger yard to mow. An oversized lot is worth what the extra square footage is worth to the next buyer, which in a community of similar lots is often less than the premium.


The test to use: would a resale buyer three years from now pay more for this lot than for the one across the street, and by how much? If the honest answer is "not by this much," the premium is a consumption decision, not an investment. That is fine. Just know which one you're making.

How to read the lot before you pay for it

Ask for the plat, the grading and drainage plan, and the community master plan showing future phases. Walk the lot after a heavy rain. Look at what is behind the preserve line on the county's future land use map, because "preserve" sometimes means "not yet built."


Check the sun orientation against the floor plan, since a west-facing lanai in Florida is a different house in August. Ask what the lot next door is approved for, and whether the builder has a two-story plan on the list for it. Find the nearest lift station, pump house, and mailbox kiosk on the site plan.


The Lot Premium Review worksheet on this site walks through each of these in order. Use it before you tour, not after you have fallen for a view.

Frequently asked questions about lot premiums

Can I get the premium waived if I buy a spec home?

More often than on a to-be-built. Spec homes carry holding cost, and the premium is usually the softest number in the price.


Is a $0 premium lot a bad lot?

Not necessarily. It usually means a standard interior lot with a rear neighbor. Those are also the lots that resell most predictably.


Does the premium get financed?

Yes. It is part of the purchase price and the appraisal has to support it. That is the second reason to be careful with large premiums.


Will the builder match the premium with incentives?

Sometimes. That is the conversation to have, and it goes better with an agent who knows what that builder has done before in that community.


What is a typical premium range in St. Johns County?

Interior lots are often $0 to $10,000. Preserve and pond lots commonly run $15,000 to $60,000. Waterfront and estate lots in communities like Shores at RiverTown can run well into six figures. Every builder prices differently, so get the lot pricing sheet for the specific phase.


Published October 14, 2026.


If you are deciding between two lots right now, call or text 561-504-4798 before you write the deposit. The lot is the one thing you can't change later.

Matthew Sodel, Real Estate Advisor & Certified New Home Specialist, Highlight Realty, FL SL3216518, 561-504-4798, matthew@newhomesjax.com, jax-property.com

Powered by

  • Shores at RiverTown
  • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
  • Regency at EverRange
  • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
  • RiverTown
  • Nocatee
  • SilverLeaf
  • EverRange
  • Compare Builders
  • Builder Lender vs. Yours
  • Ready vs. To-Build
  • New vs. Custom
  • New vs. Resale
  • Real All-In Cost
  • Lot Premium Review
  • Upgrade Scorecard
  • Floor Plan Worksheet
  • Builder Comparison
  • Real Cost of a Home
  • New Construction Buyers
  • Before You Register
  • Talk to me before touring
  • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • Privacy Policy
  • How I Work
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept