Considering New Construction? Talk to Matthew before a model home visit 561 504-4798

Jax Property
Jax Property
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Search Homes
  • Toll Brothers
    • Shores at RiverTown
    • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
    • Regency at EverRange
    • Sebastian Landing
    • Bartram Ranch
    • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
    • Communities
    • RiverTown
    • Nocatee
    • SilverLeaf
    • EverRange
  • Compare
    • Compare Builders
    • Builder Lender vs. Yours
    • Ready vs. To-Build
    • New vs. Custom
    • New vs. Resale
  • Worksheets
    • Real All-In Cost
    • Lot Premium Review
    • Upgrade Scorecard
    • Floor Plan Worksheet
    • Builder Comparison
    • Real Cost of a Home
  • Start Here
    • New Construction Buyers
    • Before You Register
    • Talk to me before touring
    • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • 55+ Buyer Guide
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews
  • More
    • Home
    • Guides
    • Search Homes
    • Toll Brothers
      • Shores at RiverTown
      • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
      • Regency at EverRange
      • Sebastian Landing
      • Bartram Ranch
      • Toll vs. Builders
    • Toll Brothers Guide
    • Communities
      • Communities
      • RiverTown
      • Nocatee
      • SilverLeaf
      • EverRange
    • Compare
      • Compare Builders
      • Builder Lender vs. Yours
      • Ready vs. To-Build
      • New vs. Custom
      • New vs. Resale
    • Worksheets
      • Real All-In Cost
      • Lot Premium Review
      • Upgrade Scorecard
      • Floor Plan Worksheet
      • Builder Comparison
      • Real Cost of a Home
    • Start Here
      • New Construction Buyers
      • Before You Register
      • Talk to me before touring
      • South Florida Relocation
    • About Matthew Sodel
    • Sell or Build First
    • 55+ Buyer Guide
    • SJC Buyer's Agent
    • Reviews
  • Home
  • Guides
  • Search Homes
  • Toll Brothers
    • Shores at RiverTown
    • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
    • Regency at EverRange
    • Sebastian Landing
    • Bartram Ranch
    • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
    • Communities
    • RiverTown
    • Nocatee
    • SilverLeaf
    • EverRange
  • Compare
    • Compare Builders
    • Builder Lender vs. Yours
    • Ready vs. To-Build
    • New vs. Custom
    • New vs. Resale
  • Worksheets
    • Real All-In Cost
    • Lot Premium Review
    • Upgrade Scorecard
    • Floor Plan Worksheet
    • Builder Comparison
    • Real Cost of a Home
  • Start Here
    • New Construction Buyers
    • Before You Register
    • Talk to me before touring
    • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • 55+ Buyer Guide
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews

The Real All-In Monthly Payment in St. Johns County

The short answer

The real all-in monthly payment on a new construction home in St. Johns County is usually 25% to 35% higher than the principal-and-interest number the builder's lender shows you. On a $650,000 home with 20% down, that gap is roughly $1,150 a month. The difference is property tax at full assessment, the CDD assessment, the HOA, and homeowners insurance.


Most buyers find this out in year two. That's the wrong time.

Why doesn't the builder's payment quote match the real number?

It isn't wrong. It's just incomplete. A builder's lender will often quote principal and interest, then estimate taxes using the current tax bill on the lot. On a new build, that lot was taxed as vacant land. The first full-year bill after you close is based on the finished home.


I cover that jump in detail in the guide Why Does My Property Tax Bill Jump in Year Two? The short version: budget for year two from day one.

What are the five pieces of the real payment?

1. Principal and interest. Set by your loan amount and rate. In late October 2026 the Freddie Mac 30-year average was about 7.3%.


2. Property tax. Unincorporated St. Johns County runs about 13.2 mills for 2026, combining the county's 6.7573 and the school district's 6.264, plus small water-management and navigation-district levies. Roughly $13.20 per $1,000 of taxable value.


3. CDD assessment. Most master-planned communities here have one. It shows up on the tax bill as a non-ad valorem line. At Shores at RiverTown, for example, FY2027 operations and maintenance runs $2,181 to $3,636 a year by lot width, plus bond debt service on top. See the Shores at RiverTown CDD Fees guide for how to read one.


4. HOA dues. Usually modest in CDD communities because the CDD funds the amenities. Budget $50 to $150 a month and confirm the current figure in the community's HOA disclosure.


5. Homeowners insurance. New construction with a new roof and wind-mitigation features tends to land toward the lower end of the county's range. One 2026 estimate puts the St. Johns County average near $2,160 a year, with quotes commonly between $1,300 and $3,500. Get a real quote before you sign.

What does a $650,000 home actually cost per month?

Here is a worked example. Round numbers, late-2026 assumptions, homesteaded.


Principal and interest: $3,547 a month ($520,000 loan, 30-year fixed, 7.25%)

Property tax, year two: about $670 a month (roughly $600,000 taxable after homestead, at about 13.2 mills)

CDD assessment: about $200 a month ($2,400 a year, mid-range; confirm by community)

HOA dues: about $100 a month (typical CDD-community HOA)

Homeowners insurance: about $200 a month (roughly $2,400 a year for new construction)


All-in: about $4,717 a month. That's roughly 33% above the principal-and-interest quote.


If you put less than 20% down, add private mortgage insurance. If your lot was taxed as land in your first year, your actual first-year tax line will be lower than $670, and then it will reset. Plan for the reset.

Does buying in a no-CDD community change the math?

Yes, by about $150 to $300 a month on paper. But the base price or the HOA is often higher to make up for it. The honest comparison is total monthly cost, not the presence or absence of one line. I walk through this in the guide Which St. Johns County Communities Have No CDD?

How do I run this for a specific home?

You'll need the base price plus lot premium and upgrades, your down payment, a rate quote, the community's CDD budget, the HOA disclosure, and an insurance quote. Fifteen minutes. It's the most useful fifteen minutes you'll spend before signing. Use the Real All-In Cost worksheet.

Frequently asked questions

Does the homestead exemption apply right away?

You apply after you close and occupy the home as your primary residence. It takes effect the following January 1. Florida's homestead exemption is up to $50,000 of assessed value, with the second $25,000 not applying to school taxes.


Is the CDD fee the same every year?

Not necessarily. The debt portion is fixed by the bond schedule. The operations and maintenance portion is set each year by the CDD board's adopted budget.


Does property tax keep rising every year?

Once homesteaded, the assessed value increase is capped at 3% a year or the change in CPI, whichever is lower (Save Our Homes). Non-homestead property is capped at 10%.


Can I negotiate any of these costs?

Not the tax, CDD, or HOA. You can negotiate the price, the rate buydown, and closing costs, which change the principal-and-interest line. That's where having your own agent matters.

Want the number run on a home you're considering?

Send me the community and the price sheet. I'll send the math back. No obligation. Call or text 561-504-4798, or email matthew@newhomesjax.com.


Matthew Sodel, Real Estate Advisor and Certified New Home Specialist, Highlight Realty. Independent buyer representation for new construction in Jacksonville and St. Johns County.

Matthew Sodel, Real Estate Advisor & Certified New Home Specialist, Highlight Realty, FL SL3216518, 561-504-4798, matthew@newhomesjax.com, jax-property.com

Powered by

  • Shores at RiverTown
  • Newbrook at SilverLeaf
  • Regency at EverRange
  • Toll vs. Builders
  • Toll Brothers Guide
  • Communities
  • RiverTown
  • Nocatee
  • SilverLeaf
  • EverRange
  • Compare Builders
  • Builder Lender vs. Yours
  • Ready vs. To-Build
  • New vs. Custom
  • New vs. Resale
  • Real All-In Cost
  • Lot Premium Review
  • Upgrade Scorecard
  • Floor Plan Worksheet
  • Builder Comparison
  • Real Cost of a Home
  • New Construction Buyers
  • Before You Register
  • Talk to me before touring
  • South Florida Relocation
  • About Matthew Sodel
  • Sell or Build First
  • Privacy Policy
  • How I Work
  • SJC Buyer's Agent
  • Reviews

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept