Considering New Construction? Talk to Matthew before a model home visit 561 504-4798
Considering New Construction? Talk to Matthew before a model home visit 561 504-4798
A short list, and it changes as new phases plat. As of October 2026 the new-construction communities most consistently sold without a Community Development District are Bartram Ranch, Mill Creek Forest, SilverLeaf's villages including Newbrook and Reverie, Oxford Estates, Las Calinas, and Cimarrone.
Bartram Ranch (Toll Brothers, St. Johns off Longleaf Pine Parkway): luxury single-family on larger lots, no CDD. The newest of the no-CDD Toll communities and the one most relocating buyers in the $800K-plus range ask about first.
Mill Creek Forest (Toll Brothers, St. Johns): two collections, Meadows at roughly 1,918 to 2,491 square feet and Magnolia at roughly 2,457 to 3,440, per published listing data. No CDD.
Newbrook at SilverLeaf and Reverie at SilverLeaf (Toll Brothers and Dream Finders, St. Augustine side of CR-210): SilverLeaf was developed without a district. A master HOA plus a village HOA replaces the CDD line. Reverie is the 55+ village and its HOA is expected to step up once the clubhouse opens.
Oxford Estates (MasterCraft, Providence, David Weekley, Drees; off Longleaf Pine Parkway): no CDD, with published HOA figures under roughly $1,300 a year depending on phase.
Las Calinas (Pulte, Taylor Morrison, Dostie; off US-1, St. Augustine): no CDD, marketed on a low HOA.
Cimarrone Golf & Country Club (northwest St. Johns): established gated golf community, no CDD, HOA around $1,500 a year per public listings. Mostly resale with occasional new builds.
Samara Lakes (World Golf Village area): no CDD and a notably low HOA per published listings, mostly resale.
These are drawn from published listing data and third-party agent reports as of October 2026, not from district records. Confirm on the specific parcel before you rely on any of it.
A CDD assessment has two pieces: a bond debt line that runs about 30 years and an operations line that runs forever. In the newest St. Johns County districts the combined figure on a single-family lot commonly lands between $2,000 and $5,000 a year. Rivers Edge III at Shores at RiverTown, for example, carries a FY2027 operations line of $2,181 to $3,636 by lot width before the debt portion is added.
A no-CDD community moves the infrastructure cost into the lot price and the amenity cost into the HOA. You still pay for the roads, the stormwater system, and the pool. You pay for them differently, up front and through the association, instead of on the tax bill over three decades.
On a $650,000 house, the difference between a $3,000 CDD line and none is roughly $250 a month, for as long as you own it. That is real. Whether it is a saving depends on what the no-CDD community charges you instead.
Higher base lot pricing, because the developer financed the infrastructure privately instead of with tax-exempt district bonds. And an HOA that has to carry amenities and common areas on its own.
The HOA in a no-CDD community is often higher than in a CDD community, and it is the number to watch, because an HOA board can raise it with far less process than a CDD board. Published figures as of October 2026 put Oxford Estates under about $1,300 a year and Cimarrone around $1,500 a year; Newbrook carries a master HOA plus a village HOA that are quoted separately. Get the current budget and the last three years of dues from the association, not the sales office.
Ask two questions of every no-CDD community: what did the HOA cost three years ago, and what is in the reserve study. The first tells you the trend. The second tells you whether a special assessment is coming.
Pull any sold parcel in the community on the St. Johns County Property Appraiser site and look at the tax bill's non-ad valorem section. If there is no district line, there is no CDD. Then read the builder's contract: Florida Statute 190.048 requires a CDD disclosure in the purchase contract for any lot inside a district. No disclosure, no district. Do both. Marketing material is not a source, and neither is this page.
Is no CDD always better? No. It is better when the HOA is reasonable and the lot premium reflects the trade. It is worse when the developer priced the infrastructure into the lots aggressively and the HOA is already climbing.
Run the all-in monthly number for a specific house in a no-CDD community against a comparable house in a CDD community over your expected hold period. Sometimes the CDD house wins on cash flow for the first ten years, and the no-CDD house wins at resale. That is the actual comparison, and it only works with real numbers on real lots.
Does Nocatee have a CDD?
Yes. Its districts cover essentially all of the community.
Does RiverTown have a CDD?
Yes, three of them: Rivers Edge, Rivers Edge II, and Rivers Edge III. RiverTown-Meadows is marketed without a CDD debt fee. Confirm on the parcel.
Does SilverLeaf have a CDD?
It was developed without one. Third-party reports describe some sections as CDD-free and are silent on others, so confirm on the specific parcel rather than the community name.
Does Bartram Ranch have a CDD?
No. It is one of the few new Toll Brothers communities in St. Johns County sold without a district.
Can a community add a CDD later?
A district can be established on undeveloped land under Chapter 190, but it cannot be imposed on lots already sold without the owners' involvement. Existing homes in a no-CDD community stay that way.
Is a no-CDD HOA always higher?
Often, not always. The HOA carries what the district would otherwise fund. Compare the HOA plus any club or amenity fee against the CDD plus HOA in the alternative community.
Published October 14, 2026. Community list and HOA figures come from published listing data and third-party agent reports as of that date. Confirm every figure on the specific parcel at the St. Johns County Property Appraiser site before you sign.
If you want the all-in monthly number on a no-CDD house against a CDD house you're also considering, call or text 561-504-4798. It takes about twenty minutes and it usually changes the decision.
Matthew Sodel, Real Estate Advisor & Certified New Home Specialist, Highlight Realty, FL SL3216518, 561-504-4798, matthew@newhomesjax.com, jax-property.com
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.