Considering New Construction? Talk to Matthew before a model home visit 561 504-4798
Considering New Construction? Talk to Matthew before a model home visit 561 504-4798
It depends on three things: whether you want to pay a CDD assessment, how far you want to be from the beach, and whether you're buying for the amenity or the house. Nocatee is closest to the coast, with a CDD. RiverTown is riverfront, with a CDD that varies by village. SilverLeaf has no CDD at all.
Nocatee: CDD assessment plus HOA. Nocatee's districts cover essentially the whole community, and the per-home figure varies by neighborhood and product type. Pull the specific parcel on the St. Johns County Property Appraiser site to see the current line.
RiverTown: CDD roughly $1,500 to $2,600 a year for single-family in most villages, around $920 for townhomes, and higher in the newest sections. Shores at RiverTown's FY2027 operations line alone runs $2,181 to $3,636 depending on lot width, with bond debt on top (see the Shores CDD fees guide for the full numbers). HOA roughly $112 to $183 a month for single-family. RiverTown-Meadows is marketed with no CDD debt fee.
SilverLeaf: no CDD. Two associations, a master and a neighborhood HOA, billed differently for townhomes and single-family. Published listing data for Newbrook shows a master HOA plus a village HOA; get both current figures from the builder before you compare.
What that means in practice: on a $650,000 house, the difference between a $2,500 CDD line and none is roughly $200 a month before taxes and insurance, for as long as you own the house. That is the number to put next to the amenity brochure.
Nocatee sits in Ponte Vedra, east of US-1 and closest of the three to the Atlantic beaches, the Town Center retail, and the Mayo Clinic corridor. Roughly 15 to 20 minutes to Ponte Vedra Beach, 30 to 40 to downtown Jacksonville depending on the Butler Boulevard backup.
RiverTown is on the St. Johns River off CR-210 west of I-95, roughly 35 to 45 minutes to downtown Jacksonville or the beaches and about 30 minutes to St. Augustine. It is the furthest of the three from the coast and the closest to the river.
SilverLeaf sits between them along CR-210 and SR-16, with the shortest run to I-95 of the three. Roughly 25 to 35 minutes to downtown Jacksonville, 20 to 25 to St. Augustine, and 30 to 40 to the beaches.
All three depend on CR-210 or Butler Boulevard at rush hour, and both corridors are under active widening. Drive the commute at 7:30 on a weekday before you decide. Times above are typical, not guaranteed.
Nocatee's amenity package is the most extensive and the most mature of the three: Splash and Spray water parks, Nocatee Town Center, a long greenway and trail network, dog parks, and a resident shuttle. You pay for it in the CDD and HOA, and it is the reason the community commands the prices it does.
RiverTown's identity is the river. Riverfront parks, the RiverClub and RiverHouse amenity centers, the newer RiverLodge on the Shores side, pools, a kayak launch, and trails along the St. Johns. If your weekends are on the water, nothing else in the county matches it.
SilverLeaf's amenity centers are newer and still opening by phase, so what you can actually use the year you close depends on where you buy. The trade for no CDD is that the amenity build-out is paced by the developer and the HOA, not front-loaded with district bonds. Ask for the amenity schedule in writing before you sign.
Nocatee: multiple builders across dozens of neighborhoods, from townhomes to estate lots, with the broadest price spread of the three. Published listings in late 2026 run from the $400Ks for townhomes and attached product to well over $1.5 million in the estate neighborhoods, with most single-family new construction between the $600Ks and $1.2 million.
RiverTown: Mattamy Homes as master developer (Meadows, Forest, Cove, Springs, and the 55+ WaterSong) and Toll Brothers at Shores at RiverTown. Roughly mid-$200Ks to about $695K across the Mattamy collections, with Shores running from the $700Ks into seven figures on the riverfront lots.
SilverLeaf: several builders including Toll Brothers at Newbrook and Dream Finders at Reverie (55+), with others selling at overlapping price points. Published listings in late 2026 put most single-family new construction between the $500Ks and $900Ks, with Newbrook's larger plans above that.
These are listing-data ranges, not builder price sheets. Base prices change monthly and every builder adds lot premiums and design studio spend on top. Get the current sheet for the specific collection before you compare.
All three are in the St. Johns County School District, which holds an A grade from the Florida Department of Education and is the reason a large share of relocating buyers look at this county first.
Zoning is by address and has been redrawn before in all three communities as new schools open. Many RiverTown addresses feed Freedom Crossing Academy (K-8) and Bartram Trail High. Nocatee addresses are split across several elementary and K-8 schools with Allen D. Nease High as the common high school for most of the community. SilverLeaf addresses have been rezoned as the community has grown, and a new K-8 inside the community has been part of the county's plan.
Check the specific address with the district's attendance zone lookup before you sign, not after. A builder's "zoned for" statement is accurate on the day it is printed and nothing more.
New construction competes with the builder's own inventory for years after you close. The community with the most active builder sales when you want to sell is the one where your resale is hardest, because the builder can always add an incentive you can't.
Nocatee's newest neighborhoods and SilverLeaf's active phases are where that pressure is highest today. RiverTown's older Mattamy villages have mostly sold through, which is why resales there compete mainly with each other. Shores at RiverTown is still in active Toll Brothers sales and will be for several more years.
That is not a reason to avoid any of the three. It is a reason to buy a lot and a floor plan the builder isn't still offering next door at a discount in year three. Ask how many lots remain in the phase, what the builder's exit timeline is, and which plans are being retired. Those three answers tell you more about your resale than the model home does.
Which has the lowest monthly cost?
Usually SilverLeaf, because there is no CDD line. Compare the HOA totals before assuming, since no-CDD communities often carry a higher HOA.
Which is closest to the beach?
Nocatee, by a wide margin.
Which has the best schools?
They share a district. Zoned schools differ by address. Check the address, not the community.
Can I avoid the CDD inside Nocatee or RiverTown?
RiverTown-Meadows is marketed without a CDD debt fee. Nocatee's districts cover essentially the whole community. Confirm on the specific parcel at the St. Johns County Property Appraiser site.
Which is best for resale?
The one where the builder has finished selling by the time you list. Today that favors RiverTown's older villages. In three years it may not.
Which is best for a family relocating from out of state?
It depends on whether the commute runs to the beaches and Mayo (Nocatee), to I-95 and St. Augustine (SilverLeaf), or doesn't run at all (RiverTown). Start with where the job is.
Published October 14, 2026. Figures are from published listing data and district budgets as of that date and change often. Confirm every number on the specific lot before you sign.
If you're deciding between these three right now, call or text 561-504-4798. I will run the all-in monthly number on a specific house in each one.
Matthew Sodel, Real Estate Advisor & Certified New Home Specialist, Highlight Realty, FL SL3216518, 561-504-4798, matthew@newhomesjax.com, jax-property.com
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.